|
Wuhlheide, Berlin |
|
Capacity: 17,000
Concert starts: 7:30pm (doors open at 5:30pm)
Address of venue: Parkbuehne Wuhlheide, An der Wuhlheide 187, 12459 Berlin-Koepenick, Germany. MAP
Website: www.wuhlheide.de
SET LIST
FIRST HALF: In
The Flesh, Mother, Set The Controls For the Heart Of The Sun, Shine On
You Crazy Diamond, Have A Cigar, Wish You Were Here, Southampton Dock,
The Fletcher Memorial Home, Perfect Sense parts 1 and 2, Leaving
Beirut, Sheep.
SECOND HALF: Dark Side of the Moon. ENCORE: The Happiest Days Of Our Lives, Another Brick In The Wall (Pt 2), Vera, Bring the Boys back Home, Comfortably Numb. |
COMMENTS
The fourth show on Roger's Dark
Side Of The Moon tour took in a pleasant venue, in the midst of a park,
on the outskirts of Berlin. With a strict curfew governing the
finishing time of the concert (we found this out from drummer Graham
Broad the next day) the first half of the show took place in strong
daylight, with most of the projections unviewable and the light show
neutered.
However, this seemed to spur the
band into putting even more energies into their performance, and the
packed amphitheatre loved every minute. Aptly enough, as the band
launched into Dark Side, the almost full moon could be clearly seen
hovering above the stage!
A thoroughly impressive
performance, highlights came thick and fast - from Sheep (an
underplayed classic, that sounded wonderful - keep it in the set,
guys!), On The Run (wow - was this LOUD!), Perfect Sense 1 and 2, and
even Leaving Beirut, which many were nervously awaiting. In the live
setting, the song works really well - it's powerful, affecting, and in
places, amusing. The accompanying film really adds to the song, and,
thankfully, by the time Roger got to this song, the light was starting
to dip a little.
Special mention should be made of
the excellent sound throughout the show. This was crisp, clear and
pretty loud, and the quad effects were perfect. The surround stacks,
whilst fairly small, packed a mean punch, particularly during the likes
of Sheep. As for On The Run - well, it has to be seen and heard in its
new version to believe it!
A nice touch - if unintentionally
amusing - was the appearance of an inflatable spaceman at one point.
Why amusing? The roadie dragging it around the stage was clearly
visible due to the lack of night-time in the arena...
There is growing talk of Roger
lip-syncing throughout the show - from where we were, there was
absolutely no sign of this. If he DOES, it can only be minor bits - the
odd line that might wreck his voice if he did it each night.
The show moves now to the Arrow
Rock Festival in Lichtenvoorde. If you are going to it, have a great
time, and let us know how it went!
SHOW REVIEW
By Brain Damage contributor, Chris Passmore
My first time in Berlin (from
Rhode Island, USA), and some great memories - the zoo, having a
Bratswurst, touring the city...and oh yeah, the Roger Waters show!! I
am 20 years old and this is truly a treat.
The gates opened at about 5:45,
and seeing as how it was general admission, I sprinted as soon as we
were let in to get front row!! The show began at about 7:45pm, only
after playing exclusively Bob Dylan and Neil Young for the 2 hours
until show time (Rog's fave singers?).
Roger came out and began In the
Flesh, and I felt it was going to be a great night - he was so
animated, excited, and truly living every moment. Wow, what a rush!!
I must say, Have a Cigar,
stripped of all the studio effects, was rockin!!!!!!! Roger sang vocals
and added his own touch, but man - I never realized what a great riff
this song has! All the songs were amazing - Fletcher, Perfect Sense,
and Leaving Beirut were the most emotional - it even seemed as though
Roger was tearing up at some parts, and I felt the same. To hear
Roger's intro to Beirut, and seeing the words on the screen, was truly
touching.
DSOTM was at it's best! 'Nuff
said! The show closed with a bang at about 10:30 and I went back to our
hotel in Berlin and had my mind full of the great music played for us.
Roger was absolutely enjoying himself, waving to the crowd, moving from
stage left to stage right, and encouraging the crowd to sing along.
I loved Gilmour's concert front row in NYC; he hypnotized me with his voice and guitar...but Roger had us rockin' all night!!!!
SHOW REVIEW
By Brain Damage contributor, Klaus Boldt
So yesterday I was at Roger's
concert in Berlin. And wow, what an evening! I went to Berlin by train
and used most of the day to stroll around in the city since I am not in
Berlin every day. The weather was great, and that was a pleasant
surprise after the last weeks.
Around 6 p.m. I made my way to
Wuhlheide. I expected to be really early, but with a large stream of
other people clad in various Floyd-related shirts I reached an already
large crowd at the gates. Luckily, when I turned my head I saw a much
larger crowd behind me. And I managed to get a really good spot about
eight rows from the stage surrounded by a lot of hardcore fans who
cheered for about everything that happened on the empty stage, be it a
quick appearance of Jon Carin to check on his keyboards or a huge
applause for Roger's bass being tuned.
After one and a half hour later
which I spent talking with other fans it finally began. They played a
set list like with the shows before with slightly shifted songs - see
above.
Shine On was a bit butchered with
the first guitar solo missing and also without the second half, but the
rest of the first half more than made up for that. He included
fireworks and flame throwers at the front of the stage at the beginning
of In The Flesh, new back projections (which were difficult to see in
the beginning because the sun was still up) and an inflatable astronaut
for Perfect Sense.
Roger seemed to have tremendous
fun up there, especially with the material that he didn't play before.
Have A Cigar needs a special mention here which really rocked!
Leaving Beirut included the before-mentioned black and white cartoons instead of a narration. Roger simply sang the verses.
Fittingly the moon came up during
the second half of the show. By the time of the encore it was finally
dark and Roger left to frantic applause.
They had no speakers in the back
of the crowd that I could see [Matt's note: yes, they did!]. Sometimes
Roger seemed to struggle a bit with a sore throat, but that didn't stop
him, nor did it stop his fans, not did it stop the show being one of
the best shows I've been to. When I saw Roger in 2002 in Hannover I sat
right at the back of the arena and from my point of view I got none of
the interaction between the band and the audience. This time Roger was
right there in front of me, and he seemed to have a great time as well.
SHOW REVIEW
By Brain Damage contributor, Harri Porten
The concert venue was nicely
located in a park in the eastern outskirts of Berlin. Concert-goers
arriving via the Wuhlheide railway station had the entertaining
opportunity to evade the 15 minute walk
to entrance by riding a historic train through the wood.
A warm and sunny day was about
end, the organizing crew was friendly and had a variety of drinks and
food up for sale. Too attractive for many apparently: the flow of
sausage and beer fans forcing themselves up and down the stairs and
between the benches never ebbed away during the course of the show.
Disapproved by others that constantly had to make way and had their
sight blocked.
The audience started to cheer
when first the band and then, a few, well-timed seconds later Waters
entered the stage. In The Flesh served as the usual opening and sound
check song. The rest of the first half of the concert was made up of a
diverse mix of songs as old as Set The Controls For The Heart of The
Sun and as new as Leaving Beirut. The latter was played as a sound
track for a comic strip shown on the
screen at the back of the stage.
Unfortunately, the deep and at
the same time somewhat narrow layout of the stage barred large parts of
the audience from fully enjoying the projections. But clearly visible
to everyone was a inflatable astronaut puppet that floated across the
stage during the first part of Perfect Sense. The quadrophonic sound
effects, e.g. for Sheep (personal favourite song of the concert) added
to the overall good sound experience.
Despite his voice sounding rather
hoarse during his announcements Waters seemed to be in good mood and
performed well. In his typical fashion he occasionally walked to both
ends of the stage to directly
address the crowd in the respective corner. The vocals and guitar play
of Dave Kilminster made him a good addition to the band. Until the
guitar roadie came for rescue one could see him fighting with his
sound effect setup more than once, though. Jon Carin, supported by full
bearded Harry Waters, took a break from his keyboards and played some
guitar parts instead.
After the break the audience
witnessed a smooth and fantastic performance of The Dark Side Of The
Moon (with the real moon up in the sky behind the stage) followed by
some songs from The Wall with
Comfortably Numb closing the concert.
All in all, the concert featured
a diverting and well performed collection of music by Roger Waters.
Definitely a worthwhile and memorable event for all of his fans. I had
only wished for a reduced
overlap with the In The Flesh and last Pink Floyd tour programs.
SHOW REVIEW
By Brain Damage contributor, Hans-Juergen Mueller
The Wuhlheide in Berlin is a
fantastic location for an Open Air show: like an old amphitheatre! The
weather was marvellous with a blue sky and an almost full moon
wandering over the top of the stage, while Roger performed 'The Dark
Side Of The Moon' - what an impression!
The first part of the show
included besides the 2 parts of 'Perfect Sense' and the new song
'Leaving Beirut' only songs from Waters' Pink Floyd era. So even less
solo songs than during his last tour. Why? He could play a whole
evening only with his solo stuff!
The show started at 7:41 pm and
the sun was still there, so that you could hardly see anything on the
huge screen (exception: Leaving Beirut). But in the second part, you
could see all the videos.
Roger had a few problems with his
voice and he sounded sometimes really hoarse. His band was really good,
with the exception of a certain Dave Kilminster. He had nothing better
to do than whirling around his long hair and dramatically rising the
neck of his poison-green guitar. That was ridiculous! Better would have
been a bit more concentration on his guitar playing! In the end, you
could see(hear), that even 2 guitar players (a questionable Dave
Kilminster and a great Snowy White) couldn't bring back the
magic of one David Gilmour.
Interesting though, that the
fantastic Andy Fairweather Low was even more in the background as on
the last tour. Anything else: Business as usual.
They played a good show, that
will be remembered for the new stage design. I loved especially the
following songs: 'Have A Cigar', 'The Fletcher Memorial Home', 'Perfect
Sense (II)', 'Sheep', a very dynamic 'Us And Them', 'Vera' and 'Bring
The Boys Back Home'. Sadly enough, the best song and mainly the
highlight of every show, 'Comfortably Numb' was because of the
participation of Dave Kilminster nothing special.
After 140 minutes of music the
show was finally over. All in all a good show, but for some reason I
still have this question of one of the fans in my ear: 'Was this a Pink
Floyd coverband with Roger Waters?' There's nothing to add to this!
SHOW REVIEW
By Brain Damage contributor, Matthias Sturner
I have seen Waters both in 1999
and 2002 a couple of times and frankly speaking, I think these tours
were better than his recent show in Berlin.
Ok, we now know that it was not
his decision to start the show so early in the evening, but playing Set
the Controls in broad sunshine is a little bit ridiculous (why not
moving it to the encores?). From near the stage the daylight was not
bad because you could really see well what was going on on stage, but I
felt sorry for everyone sitting in the back being left without any
light show. It was only beginning to get dark during the second half of
Dark Side when the light show was slowly getting impressive. I liked it
best during Any Colour You Like, which was featuring a great new film.
However, I found the fence-like lighting structure behind the stage
which partly covered the screen (at least from the front) a bit
disturbing and useless.
On to the music: the selection of
the songs was quite disappointing. Obviously Waters doesn't like much
of what he has done after the 70's. I mean come on, 1 new song + 1 song
from the 90's + 2 songs from the 80's, but all the rest was more than
26 years old! As if he didn't have other more recent stuff to offer. I
didn't like at all Vera + Bring the boys back home. Dark Side was ok,
but it was like being played by a cover band. Sorry, but this piece
definitely needs the guitar and voice of David Gilmour to sound great.
It was exactly played like the album version, no previously unheard
extensions as it had been announced some weeks before the show. The
only minor change was the addition of some seconds of new sound effects
during On The Run. Despite the fact that I didn't like the selection of
the songs, the first half of the concert was played really great.
Waters was singing and performing like I have never seen him before,
full of energy. He really didn't seem to care that he still has many
months of touring in front of him. It was great to hear Sheep live
finally.
Regarding the lip-syncing, I'm
sure he doesn't do it in the first set (after all, he didn't play Every
Stranger's Eyes...), during Dark Side he almost never sings anyway, so
probably the lip-syncing happens during the encores. My guess is that
most of the orchestration is also coming from tape and that parts of
Vera and Bring the Boys Back Home are indeed lip-synced (did I mention
before that I don't like these songs at all?).
The other musicians are playing
tight. Jon Carin really saves Dark Side from becoming mediocre and
generally seems the one holding it all together. The backing singers
are really great (each one of them). David Kilminster played well.
Waters made a couple of mistakes on bass, but he is backed-up on bass
during the more difficult pieces by Andy Fairweather-Low and also by
Ian Ritchie during Comfortably Numb! I am thinking hard, but I think I
have never seen any band featuring 2 bass guitars!
All in all, the show is worth to be seen, but it is nothing like the current David Gilmour tour.
SHOW REVIEW
By Brain Damage contributor, Ed Sinclair
Having previously been to the
final show of David Gilmour's 3 night residency of the Albert Hall, it
suffices to say that this concert certainly had a big act to follow!
Well, it didn't just match the quality of last Wednesday, it surpassed
it!
Firstly, the venue. Set in a
woodland area, it is a large amphitheatre with seating around the
periphery as well as the opportunity to stand in the central arena. The
sound and acoustics were superb, no instruments were drowned out at the
expense of others and best of all, there were speakers around the
outside, giving a surround sound feel when the DSOTM sound effects were
being played.
The show began at 1930, the arena
was well attended but by no means full, so standing in the centre, it
was possible to get right up close. Roger Waters and the band appeared,
Roger looked extremely cheerful and pleased to be touring again. He
chose the usual show opener "In the Flesh" before moving onto a variety
of Floyd and Solo songs.
I was especially pleased to hear
"Have a Cigar" which sounded fantastic. With SOYCD, it seems that like
David, Roger now favours his own arrangement. Gone is the guitar intro,
instead, we are left with the keyboards and it jumps straight to "Syd's
tune". It was extremely nice to hear some tracks from the Final Cut.
They played Southampton Dock and The Fletcher Memorial Home. Roger
appeared to mime part of the latter, but understandable considering the
strain those high notes would place on his voice.
His solo work always sounds great
live. I feel it's the only context that does it justice. Perfect Sense
had the crowd chanting along in the chorus and PP Arnold sang
beautifully. We heard the new song- "Leaving Beirut", which was
extremely moving, made all the more so by the cartoon narrative which
played on the overhead screen. On the subject of back projections, the
concert started too early really to see them properly, which was a
pity. The only part of the 1st half I felt didn't work was the
performance of Sheep. I felt it lost its manic energy and would have
preferred to have heard Dogs or Pigs in its place. Roger played the
former excellently last time I saw him in 2002.
The band took a short break and
came back with the highly anticipated performance of DSOTM. Jon Carin
played excellent lap steel on Breathe and On The Run was brilliant as
it had some crazy added screams and effects which resonated around the
arena thanks to the surround sound. The album began in earnest and was
a joy to listen to. Dave Kilmister is an outstanding guitarist and
faithfully reproduced the Gilmour parts note for note. Gone is Andy
Fairweather Low's short blast in Money. Any Colour You Like is such a
great track, sadly rarely performed live, but on this occasion, as on
Pulse, it was blistering.
The band left the stage after
finishing Eclipse. They returned a few seconds later for the encores
which were Happiest Days/Another Brick. There was a slight technical
hitch with the "Stand still laddie" intro. Interestingly Vera and Bring
The Boys back home were also played. Finally CN concluded the show,
leaving the audience on a high.
All in all a great gig, those attending Hyde Park are in for a treat!
var sc_project=585857;
var sc_partition=4;
var sc_security="a69cc800";
<a xhref="http://www.statcounter.com/" target="_blank"><img xsrc="http://c5.statcounter.com/counter.php?sc_project=585857&java=0&security=a69cc800"
alt="website stat" border="0"></a>
|